Debating
|
|
Team
|
Opponent
|
Result
|
Matter-Method-Manner-Overall
|
Comment
|
| Topic |
That we should set a maximum wage of $1 million for corporate executives. |
|
A1
|
Sacre Coeur 1
|
W
|
92-46-93-231 to 91-45-31-227
|
A convincing win and excellent start to the season. Best Speaker: Branwell Travers |
|
A2
|
Sacre Coeur 4
|
W
|
Win by forfeit
|
In a scratch debate against Bialik 1, Matthew Daniel was the best speaker. |
|
A3
|
Xavier College 1
|
L
|
90-43-89-222 to 90-43-91-224
|
Best Speaker: Thomas Kelly |
|
A4
|
Bye
|
|
|
|
|
A5
|
Sacre Coeur 5
|
L
|
87-40-88-215 to 87-42-89-218
|
Best Speakers: Harry Hatzis & Christopher Smart |
| Topic |
That the police should not carry guns on the beat. |
|
B1
|
Sacre Coeur 1
|
L
|
90-45-86-221 to 89-48-86-223
|
Best Speaker: Henry Shirer |
|
B2
|
Xavier College 5
|
W
|
92-46-90-227 to 91-44-91-226
|
Best Speaker: Giancarlo Tymms |
|
B3
|
Xavier College 4
|
L
|
92-44-91-227 to 90-45-93-228
|
Best Speakers: Timothy McDonald and Jeremy Guinane |
|
B4
|
Xavier College 3
|
L
|
92-44-89-226 to 94-44-91-229
|
Best Speaker: James Gallus |
| Topic |
That Australia should adopt a national internet filter |
|
C1
|
Sacre Coeur 1
|
W
|
91-46-89-226 to 90-44-91-225
|
Best Speaker: Alexander Nguyen |
|
C2
|
Bialik College 1
|
W
|
89-45-90-224 to 88-44-88-221
|
Best Speakers: Felix Mason & Thomas Kuiper |
|
C3
|
Xavier College 1
|
L
|
90-45-90-225 to 90-45-91-226
|
Best Speaker: John Leach |
|
C4
|
Sacre Coeur 4
|
L
|
89-45-89-223 to 90-45-90-225
|
Best Speaker: Arran Brady |
| Topic |
That we should ban cosmetic surgery |
|
D1
|
Sacre Coeur 1
|
W
|
92-44-90-226 to 89-44-89-222
|
Best Speaker: Matthew Jarrett |
|
D2
|
Bialik College 1
|
W
|
Win by forfeit
|
|
|
D3
|
Xavier College 1
|
L
|
90-45-90-225 to 91-44-91-226
|
Best Speaker: Roland Stagg |
|
D4
|
Bialik College 2
|
L
|
90-44-91-225 to 91-44-92-227
|
Best Speaker: Nicholas Brown |
